Friday, April 12, 2013

The worst advice we give to girls



“Be nice.”

“Be patient.”

“You catch more bees/flies with honey than with salt/vinegar.”

I’m still getting this advice from well-meaning women in my life. Let me tell you something. This advice isn’t useful and doesn’t help. In fact, it only serves to exacerbate the feeling that my problem is in a black hole being ignored.

I’m having serious problems right now related to my home, damages, my insurance company, and the public adjuster company that I hired to help me resolve the issues. I will get into the details later once it is all over – because believe me, I have plenty to say. But this is the issue that prompted this post and that’s all you need to know.

Being a woman in American society is a liability in many ways. Women are meant to be nice, patient, kind, compassionate, and above all, not get angry. Because that’s not ladylike, feminine, appropriate.

I call bullshit.

When companies or individuals are ignoring you after you’ve paid for a service, or not doing their jobs, or just being mean/inappropriate/ineffective for the situation, being nice and patient doesn’t resolve the problem.

When we tell young girls, young women, and even 40-something women to be “nice,” “patient,” and “don’t get so upset,” what we are really saying is “don’t stand up for yourself” and “don’t fight.”

Again, I call bullshit.

Anyone who has known me since my 20s knows that my temper is now in admirable control and I don’t often get angry. Yoga and meditation helped a lot with that self-improvement. And I do consider that an extraordinary feat of self-improvement. Being nice, patient, compassionate, and all of those other “positive” qualities have helped me to develop into a better friend, better daughter, better girlfriend/life partner, better teacher. But so has my anger and sense of righteousness; my ability to stand up for myself, negotiate and argue on my own behalf. And yet, we don’t value these “negative” aspects of being human – especially in women.

Rejecting these qualities in women is wrong.

Advising against these qualities in women is detrimental.

Being angry all the time is counterproductive, trust me on that. But never getting angry? Never hearing that it is ok, appropriate, and acceptable to get angry when the situation calls for it, to advocate vigorously for ourselves? Talk about telling girls to avoid a necessary life skill that is, indeed, more important than cooking, looking pretty, and being peacemakers.

This advice and the impulse that causes women to express such advice to girls and other women is toxic, detrimental, and needs to stop.

The most consistent advocates for getting angry and defending myself when the situation warrants it are men.

Ladies, we should take a cue from the men in our lives and learn to embrace the necessity and value of anger and verbal/written self-defense instead of telling each other and the young women in our lives to calm down, be patient, and be nice. That only works for doormats.

And we are not doormats. We are women. Women with value in all of our emotional and intellectual complexity. Women who aren’t “over-reacting” or “being hysterical” when we are justifiably upset.  Women who are still women with value even when we get mad and stand up for ourselves.

So let’s stop advising each other to be doormats.

Friday, January 11, 2013

When symbolism isn't enough

As I write this, people and pieces of the story are moving and the situation will inevitably change again by the time I publish this post.

The story I refer to is the Idle No More movement, and more specifically, the meeting in Ottawa scheduled today (Friday, Jan. 11, 2013) between some First Nations chiefs and high-ranking politicians, including Prime Minister Steven Harper and the British Crown's man in Canada, Governor General David Johnston.

I've been watching this story with great interest and hope because the time is well past due for Indigenous peoples to rise up collectively and force the government's hand to deal with them as sovereign nations. Although this is a Canadian region indigenous movement, I also think about the U.S. government, and hope that the tribal nations here will follow suit. Western governments dealing unfairly and downright dishonestly with Native peoples is not new - at least not to anyone who has read about these historical and contemporary issues. According to this writer, I am one of those "mushy progressive-types," as well as a "dogmatic" Indigenous studies academic (curse my existence!) who won't give up on this movement or Attawapisket Chief Theresa Spence.

For those of you who may not know, Chief Spence went on a hunger strike on Dec. 11, 2012 to force the government's hand. Her demands were fairly straightforward: A meeting between herself, Prime Minister Harper, and Gov. Gen. Johnston to discuss aboriginal treaty rights. That has since grown to include many other First Nations chiefs. At first, Harper and Johnston refused to meet. And then Harper agreed to meet. Spence refused to attend until Johnston attended. He finally relented a couple of days ago.

But Chief Spence still refuses to attend the meeting, and now this potential grand symbolic moment that has much of the world's attention may fall apart.

Part of me wishes she would agree to attend so as not to lose public support of the greater cause. Being a leader sometimes means compromising - and her basic demands have been met. However, as some critics have charged, the purpose and foundation of this meeting seems to be changing - a shifting sand. It is difficult as an outsider to know what exactly was demanded initially, how those demands have changed, and how all of the players are truly responding - because all of this news is filtered through a biased media lens.

Indian Country Today Media Network presents a fairly balanced perspective, but is the Indigenous perspective, so is naturally sympathetic.

All other news outlets seem to be mildly to extremely negative and intent on making this entire story just go away. And it seems, there is a growing portion of the Canadian general populace that agrees. Consider these comments to this story in the Calgary Herald:

A "Top Commenter," Keith Carter, writes, "Missing Million$, and now a demand that the Queen's Representative attend or she won't? Enough of this showboating fraud. Cancel the meeting, the Indian Act and the Reserves. Time to join the rest of us in making an honest living." This comment received 21 likes at last count and one of his respondents, another "Top Commenter," Mildred Johnson, agreed, "Time for us to demand that the gov't stop giving money to these thieves, thus throwing our tax dollars after bad and giving it to the criminals on the reserves."

The public relations and media coverage of the Idle No More movement and Chief Theresa Spence's hunger strike has been generally positive until about a week ago when she first refused to attend the meeting. Many writers have pointed out that she is now losing support from non-Native allies and Native peoples alike. Yesterday, I said to a colleague that she really ought to attend this meeting, especially now that the Governor General has agreed to attend, because sometimes leaders must lead even in imperfect situations. The attention this issue has received is incredible and continues to grow. We live in an ADHD world now with all of us more susceptible to being like Doug in UP, turning at the slightest distraction away from important issues at hand. My colleague observed that Spence is the shiny object and we're all watching her...what happens if she loses our attention? Will the Idle No More Movement lose momentum? If this meeting today falls apart, doesn't that just benefit the Canadian government?

I may be a mushy, liberal, "progressive-type," pro-Indigenous rights academic, but I also live in a world of compromise (academia has taught me this lesson well). I understand Spence's position that symbolism and "ceremonial meetings" aren't enough...but it is a start. And I do hope that she attends and continues being a strong and vital leader for her Attawapisket people and all Indigenous peoples.

Monday, December 17, 2012

“We can’t tolerate this anymore”: The salve of toothless words



"We can't tolerate this anymore." But we will.

Americans are in love with violence. Our nation was born through warfare, genocide of Indigenous peoples, domination, oppression, conquest and the abuse of peoples and lands. We have always turned to violence to solve our difficult problems. Diplomacy is mocked, prevention is disallowed for fear of stepping on toes or causing embarrassment, empathy is given lip service. We distrust change.

In the aftermath of the Newtown, CT massacre, we cry and lament, we demand justice and answers, we claim to want change and vow to make things different. We scream that we "can't" tolerate these mass murders anymore. Our lawmakers look on sternly, threatening to pass new laws and restrict access to guns and increase funding for mental health services. We claim, we argue, we demand, but our words are a toothless salve to our imagined wounds. We are horrified today. We will accept more tomorrow. 

Here is the ugly truth. We are in love with violence, our deep-rooted national mother. The roots are now enmeshed into land, as much as into our spirits, our national identity, our communities, and our homes. I could easily make this argument broader and say that the human species is in love with violence, but I am speaking as an American, and so am focused on America.

Americans are in love with violence. From the genocidal conquest of the millions of Indigenous peoples not so long ago, to the wars fought in the name of money, resources, land, ideas, and revenge, to the seemingly minor and insignificant presence of violence in our everyday lives with television shows, movies, video games, insulting gossip, road rage, intolerance of difference, and looking the other way when a person’s behavior is “off.” We walk around each other on eggshells, ready to fight and argue at a moment’s notice, hair trigger tempers kept in check by weakening threads of civility.

We know what the problems are. All of us stand ready with reasons, arguments, evidence, and pleas, but none of us has the courage to admit the truth: We are in love with violence. We turn to violence as an answer – we always have. And here is the ugly truth: We always will.

The events of Newtown, CT did not occur in a vacuum. We are all culpable. We are a violent society born out of violence, forged over hundreds of years of violent acts used as resolution, and hardened and desensitized by our entertainments, our news, our daily commutes. We speak toothless words of outrage to salve our violence-loving selves. But we will not change. And this will happen again. Because we will not change.

Perhaps we really are like the Romans after all.

Monday, December 10, 2012

"What do you want?": The holiday quandary

"What do you want for Christmas," my boyfriend of almost 22 months asked me tonight on the phone. "I need some ideas."

"An oven mitt," says I.

"A what?"

"Oven mitt. I need a nice, new oven mitt."

I wasn't kidding. We spent the most recent weekend baking holiday cookies and I almost burned my fingers several times because my oven mitt is as old as I am. Ok, maybe not THAT old, but I bought it several states and several careers and several relationships ago, so that's too old. And threadbare. So, yes. I need a new oven mitt.

But that's not what he really wanted to know. He has ideas already, but wants to get me something I really want, something that is sweet and meaningful, and not wholly practical (like a bathroom floor...I tried that, too).

"Ok," says I, "Then get me something sweet and romantic and not at all practical."

"Thing is," says he, "whenever I've bought jewelry in the past, I always feel robbed. And you don't wear jewelry."

As I've said before, I repeated, "There is only one piece of jewelry I really want from you that I would wear all the time and that isn't happening anytime soon, so please don't buy me jewelry that you aren't going to feel good about and I'm not going to wear."

The conversation progressed to gifts purchased for our folks, friends, and me teasing him proudly about my gifts for him, which are undeniably awesome ;).

"The thing is, honey, what I need is for this tree in my back yard to go away. I need a renovated bathroom. I need a new laundry room floor. And myriad other jobs that you are already going to help me with. I have everything I want. I really don't need more stuff."

 I fully realize what a quandary this puts him in. Any man in this position has a difficult task - what to get when your woman is super-practical, doesn't like frilly/fluffy/sparkly stuff, and owns more than enough books, candles, bed linens, etc. What to do when you want to be sweet, romantic, and useful in the gift department?

Realizing this, as the conversation went on, I thought about it and offered two more suggestions.

"You know what I love? Travel. Take me somewhere. I love traveling and having adventures and especially doing these things and making memories with you. So take me somewhere as a gift. It doesn't have to be a two-week extravaganza. Just a weekend away doing something fun. Or get us tickets to something. Or a class we can share together."

He asked me if I still wanted to see Trans-Siberian Orchestra. He had mentioned to me previously that he has never seen them live. I have and raved about the show I saw years ago in DC. So of course I'd love to see them! He's going to try and get tickets tomorrow for Friday's show in Philly. I said, "That can be your gift, honey."

He said, "One of many."

Before we said our "sweet dreams, talk to you tomorrow," I said, "I thought of something else you can give me."

"What's that?"

"Write me a letter. I write you lots of letters. You haven't written me one in a long time. I love that kind of thing. So write me a letter. That would be a wonderful gift."

"Let me think about it."

I feel for the guy, I do. I'm not an easy woman to buy for. He's bought me tools, gifted me his physical labor, time, and expertise, helped me survive numerous unforeseen obstacles in homeowning and landlording, and I am an independent woman with all of my own stuff. And I don't wear jewelry, which is, I believe, a default "sweet, thoughtful, romantic" category. I'm hard to buy for. And I know I'm not the only woman in this position with men who love us having no idea what to do around the holidays.

So I say without irony or snark or derision, if all he gives me is a heartfelt letter, the TSO tickets, and an oven mitt, I will be very happy. Because he has already given me the greatest gift I could have possibly expected - his heart. And that is worth more to me than all of the jewels in the world.

What is your favorite gift to receive from the person who loves you?

Friday, December 7, 2012

Fight or Flight?

Heart beats harder. Stress hormones flood. Perceived threat. Panic.

"Fight or flight response...a physiological reaction found to occur in an animal when it encounters an apparent threat" (Funk & Wagnalls New World Encyclopedia).

When I was 18, I fled my parents' home so that I could fight for the life I wanted to lead. Despite their criticism of this decision and the strain on our relationship, despite suffering a robbery and violation of my new space, I pushed through, stayed on my path, (moved to a different apartment), and survived, fighting every step of the way.

Immobility. Freeze. Stop, look, listen.

At 28, a well-known writer at the writing residency I attended for a month at the Vermont Studio Center shook my hand, looked down at it, and said, "You don't have a writer's hands," and then proceeded to rip my novel to shreds.  Despite his criticism and threat to my dream, I pushed through, stayed on my path, and became a professional writer and journalist (but that novel was only sent to a few publishers, rejected, and now sits in a box).

Internal fire alarm. Instinct to flee.  

At 35, after experiencing broken bones, painful recovery, emotional trauma, and marital difficulty, I fled to Yellowstone National Park to fight for my sanity and psychological well-being. Despite the internal critic that begged me to quit, I returned home, moved to Auburn, AL (where I knew no one), began work on my doctorate, and hoped for the best.

"Today, the stresses we face are very different from what they were in prehistoric times.  Sometimes, our fight-or-flight response gets triggered when there is no actual threat to our survival.  With no external, life-threatening danger to focus on, bodily sensations and scary thoughts can spiral into a panic attack" (Panic).

At 37, after suffering the personal failure of divorce and feeling the pain of aloneness and the despair that I would never find love again, I learned to lean on my new Alabama friends to fight for the life I deserved.

Determination not to quit. Faith in goals. Strength from inside and out. Fighting.

At 38, after a terrible falling out with a committee member that resulted in me scrambling at the 11th hour to find a replacement, a professional moment of despair that almost ended my pursuit of this degree I knew I wanted, I felt psychological pain that took my breath away. The flee response was stronger than it had ever been, and yet my friends and family wouldn't let me make a terrible mistake and quit. They pushed. They reminded me how much I had achieved, how far I'd come, how committed I am to this path. So I felt the pain, the disappointment, the panic, the uncertainty, the despair...and kept going.

Faith in goal falters. Want to flee. Want to quit. Remain in place.

At 41, after buying my first home, Chase told me I hadn't paid my mortgage (despite cancelled checks that proved otherwise), and threatened to foreclose. In this moment, I anticipated the worst. I was pushed to the edge, lost faith in the system and my fellow man, questioned my own decisions, and truly felt despair and panic. My new network of friends and colleagues and an incredibly understanding and helpful boyfriend reminded me that this was just a greater-than-average bump in the road, that my decision was sound, that Chase would back off once the slow wheels of bureaucracy ground away. (They did.)

Doubt. Despair. Questions. Frozen. Chin out.

Sadly, I "inherit" this tendency to anticipate the worst from my mother. I tend to hope for the best and then feel let down when things go terribly wrong, but so many people in my life have always had the perspective that things always work out with perseverence, hard work, and a little faith. This perspective keeps me grounded and gives me hope and strength to fall back on when I feel the urge to freeze and flee.

How does the fight-or-flight response work in your life? Have you ever fled from something because of a perceived threat, only to discover later that it wasn't really as bad as you had anticipated? Or have you never fled from anything and always stood and fought?

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

The Year of the House

Oregano Spice warms my bedroom walls, the perfect "garden" backdrop for my dad's watercolor mountain and farm landscapes and a bright yellow, orange, red, green, and blue/black autumn road scene in oils. Identical gold metal frames give the threesome a purposeful feel. Balancing the paintings are three large metal trees, another threesome, this time hanging diagonally above the bed, each one with different painted leaves in muted tones - one green, one copper, one frosted white. The combination of these two types of seasonal artwork, along with the sage and eggplant painted dresser, the soft brown covered armchair, the India-inspired footstool, and the muted gold and silver sparkle of the leaf-embroidered cream comforter creates a warm, welcoming, natural feel in the bedroom.

A tweedy gray and navy suitcase stands against the open closet door, draped with a shirt and sports bra thrown there carelessly after a weekend of bucking two giant pine trees that fell on my yard during Hurricane Sandy's windy wrath. The digital video recorder case squats amidst the cords that should be wrapped neatly inside on the wide, unpainted windowsill. One windowsill and frame, three doorframes, and three doors remain to be painted the correct pale Lichen color in this room. The soft, yet brighter, hue of the Lichen balances and warms the darker Oregano Spice on the walls, but too much remains unpainted and so the vibe of the room is unfinished, halfway, sloppy. On the dresser is a small mound of folded, clean laundry waiting to be tucked into drawers and hung up in one of the two closests. The footstool is buried beneath two of the big throw pillows that belong on the bed when it's not being used. On the armchair is a larger mound of clean, folded laundry, many summer clothes that have yet to find their way into the trunk for winter storage. An outlet plate hangs unceremoniously - still not screwed into the wall. Incongruous next to the light-switch faceplates covered carefully in Monet's sunflowers.

The dark hardwood floor feels cool to my feet, warm to my eyes. Modern nature is my theme and the house came with these floors. How convenient. The archway between the living room and hallway has a quaintness that always draws comments. The built-in shelves were carefully repainted to match the woodwork color, "Day Spa," an almost white blue hue that only clashes with the main wall color, "Fresh Sky" in certain shadowed corners that only I notice, and melds perfectly with the accent wall in "Tahoe Blue." The dark chocolate corner sectional sofa, pale sand rug with leaves woven in, the dark brown DVD and chachki corner shelf, the dark black rectangle of flat-screen on the dark chocolate TV cabinet, the walnut antique entrance table, and the modern rust-gold-shaded lamp all work in harmony to create a lounging area that beckons. Quite the opposite from the home in which I grew up where furniture was not to be laid upon, no feet on the sofa, no lounging comfortably. Rather, furniture was carefully designed, with both aesthetic and functional purpose, fabric-covered museum pieces for sitting (carefully) only.

The ottoman in front of the sofa is cluttered and stacked with magazines, unopened mail, unpaid bills, a hairbrush, crumbs, a napkin, a water glass, and several pens beneath my netbook's soft black cover. The beautiful wine-barrel top serving tray that sits on the ottoman and has both beauty and function cannot be seen and is merely gathering stuff. The pass-through between the dining area and living room features tools (hammer, screwdrivers, razor knife, measuring tape, paintbrush), and papers related to my mortgage. The large round glass dining room table hosts smoke detectors for the upstairs apartment, a bag of paint samples, two rock-covered placemats, a carved-out wood stump vase filled with blue, green, and gold Christmas balls, two unused hangers from the closet shelf system, a Swiffer duster, and a small stack of paid bills atop the newest Time magazine. The beautiful hardwood floor in the dining room is streaked with mud tracked in from the yard during the tree-bucking weekend, footprints, dirt and sawdust.

I'm so frustrated with all of the things undone - the unfinished painting, the demo-chic bathroom, the laundry room mastic-covered cement floor, the pipes that need hangers in the basement so they are more secure, the unfinished office with boxes of stuff that made the move (much of which will be thrown out if I ever take an afternoon to dig through it), all of the accumulated clutter and clothes and dishes not put away, and now, two giant trees down in my yard, crushing my shed and fence, more projects and tasks to handle, more responsibilities to  pay for.

This weekend, after we had worked ourselves stiff and sore from cutting, dragging, hauling, throwing giant branches and trunk sections, my boyfriend looked at me as we both lay on the dark brown sofa in pjs, robes, and under blankets. He studied me for a moment and then asked, "Are you glad you bought this place?"

Right now, that's a loaded question because the answer seems to be less clear as time passes. Had he asked me this summer, despite all the harangue of the purchase and the annoyance of the previous tenants, and the extraordinary expense I undertook to begin making this place "mine," I would have answered quickly in the affirmative. But this Sunday, I just looked back, breathed a sigh, and said, "I don't know. I'm conflicted."

At this precise moment, thanks to a storm, a looming strike, extra unexpected expenses with house and car, and no raise for two years, my financial situation is on a knife's edge. Exactly what my parents predicted would happen if I bought a house. They always warned me that buying a house meant having to spend thousands a year on it - basic maintenance and upkeep, plus things go wrong every year - big things - things like furnaces and water heaters and foundations, oh my. My own desire to be transient was part of my decision not to buy, despite always wanting to own my own home, but the drumbeat of my parents' doubts and fears year after year made the whole process seem daunting and unappealing and worse, foolhardy.

Having done my research, saved the necessary downpayment, and gotten quite a good mortgage rate, I looked at places for six months before taking the plunge. And despite all of the difficulties with banks trading my mortgage around like a beat-up rag doll, I relished selecting paint colors, planning the look and feel inside and out, and then slowly working my way toward creating a new home reality. But now it just feels overwhelming, and my parents' admonitions about how expensive it is to own a home are inside my head, tormenting me from across time, space, and mind. Maybe they were right. Maybe I should have remained an apartment dweller. This is too much. I can't afford it - within the last two months, it has become too expensive with no sign of abating.

Then I remember that my tax return should be healthy this year. And eventually, the strike/contract situation at work will be resolved one way or the other. And I do love the Tahoe Blue accent wall, and Oregano Spice bedroom walls, and my cool/warm hardwood floors, and the comfort I feel in this space.

Comfort. And a sense that I'm getting to know this place. It really is starting to feel like it belongs to me. Working on the property and the walls and the floors, putting in sweat and time and bruises and tears creates a bond of sorts with this place. I feel comfortable here. I like it here. I enjoy changing the space and improving it, tweaking the good bones and making them better. And maybe that's enough in the Year of the House.

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

What DID the camel say when that straw broke its back?

I walk into my 3pm Advanced Composition class today, which is the same regular classroom as my 1:30 College Comp class, and see this:


I won't tell you what my Advanced Comp students said, but it was salty. A little backstory might be appropriate...

Every semester, one class has the "Bad Seed" dynamic. Ask any professor and she will nod, roll her eyes, groan, and exclaim, "Yes!" We get them every semester. Just one class in which the dynamic is rotten to the core, much like the Grinch's original heart before the Whos get to him. The dynamic varies, but always centers on some variation of "too smart for the room," "resent having to take this class," and "I don't care, you are wasting my time." Some semesters are milder than others, but just my luck, this semester, this particular class has a roiling, obvious, distaste for me, the subject, the work, you name it. I've actually ignored all smart-ass comments and all eye-rolling and all disgusted side comments. Until today.

Today, when I walked into the classroom and saw this (the second of such notes - the first was "Dr M for President (and) We LOVE College Comp! (heart symbol)" - and that was while I was sitting at the front desk meeting with students one on one. So, this class has no shame and isn't hiding the fact that they can't stand me or this class. So today, the proverbial straw broke the proverbial camel's back.

And what exactly did the camel say when this happened? Well, see for yourself:



Good evening, class. 

To the 13 students who read the not one, but TWO, emails I sent yesterday regarding our locations and class plans for the final four days of class - and who also likely read the syllabus (where this information may also be found), thank you for coming to the library and diligently working on your Project Three research today. I am sure that your hard work will pay off in excellent and well-researched essays.

And now, allow me to direct your attention to D2L and the last item in the Readings folder labeled "Visual Rhetoric created by 1:30 College Composition class." Please note that the construction of "We we're" is incorrect. The misuse of apostrophes is really quite rampant on our campus and I encourage each of you to seek out assistance to alleviate this problematic grammatical construction issue - the Writing Center's tutors are well-qualified to assist in such matters. Furthermore, there is a 15 minute rule on our campus, not 10, so you should be aware of your audience when making claims with evidence, particularly when your evidence is false - hurts your credibility. In addition, the use of the ever-popular and clearly heartfelt heart symbol should really be colored in for extra emphasis and appeal to the viewer's emotions.

Finally, I would like to ask that you disregard those two emails that I sent yesterday...and disregard the schedule listed on the syllabus. I know that our schedule has been set and in print since the semester started, but I find myself inspired and persuaded by this display of visual rhetoric acumen to change the final three classes into conference days.

Therefore, if you attended class today in the right place (due to having read both of my emails and having consulted the syllabus), or have a legitimate and verifiable excuse for your absence (read that, doctor's note, court appearance document, funeral program), then I encourage you to visit me in my office during our regular class time for the next three classes in order to receive more specific, personal, and one on one help with the development of Project Three. You may choose to bring me an outline, your first few pages, a resource that you would like help with analyzing - whatever you think would help you the most. I'm here to help you because you are putting in the time and the effort to complete this course.

The rest of you are free to do what you want with the time. Best of luck on Project Three - it is still due during our final exam time.

Best,

Dr. M